The Long Island real estate market in 2025 is presenting a diverse range of opportunities for homebuyers. With nearly 500 new listings available, the market is showing a healthy inventory of properties ranging from entry-level homes starting at $500K to luxury estates exceeding $12M. According to current market data, properties are typically receiving multiple offers, indicating strong buyer demand despite competitive pricing.

Buyers can expect to find a variety of properties across Long Island’s distinctive communities, including waterfront properties in The Hamptons and more affordable options in emerging neighborhoods like Babylon and New Port Beach. For more information on the current market trends and to explore the top listings, visit our resource page.

Key Takeaways

• Nearly 500 new homes are available for sale in Long Island.
• The median listing price is around $800K.
• Properties typically stay on the market for 34 days.
• Multiple offers are common, indicating strong buyer demand.
• Diverse properties are available, ranging from entry-level homes to luxury estates.

Long Island Real Estate Market Overview 2025

Learn More

As we dive into 2025, the Long Island real estate market shows promising trends and statistics. The market has demonstrated remarkable resilience, with a median listing price of $800K, reflecting steady appreciation in property values across most neighborhoods.

Current Market Trends and Statistics

The current data indicates that homes in Long Island typically remain on the market for just 34 days before selling, significantly faster than the national average. This rapid turnover suggests strong buyer demand. Additionally, the market has seen moderate growth with nearly 500 new listings available, providing more options for buyers compared to previous years.

Key statistics include:

• The median listing price is $800K.
• Homes stay on the market for an average of 34 days.
• Properties receive an average of 3 offers.
• 1,693 homes were sold in the past month alone.

Average Days on Market and Offer Competition

The average days on market and offer competition are crucial indicators of the real estate market’s health. With homes selling in just 34 days and receiving an average of 3 offers, the market favors sellers. This competitive environment necessitates that buyers act decisively when making an offer.

The MLS GRID data reveals that the market is vibrant, with a significant number of homes sold in the past month. This data is subject to change and is provided for informational purposes, highlighting the importance of staying updated on market trends.

Premium Neighborhoods with Top Listings in Long Island

As we look at Long Island’s real estate in 2025, certain neighborhoods emerge as particularly desirable for luxury homebuyers. These areas are known for their unique characteristics, amenities, and strong value retention.

The Hamptons Luxury Properties

The Hamptons continues to represent the pinnacle of Long Island luxury real estate in 2025, with median listing prices around $2.3 million for properties that offer exclusive amenities and often waterfront access. These luxury homes are highly sought after for their expansive grounds and high-end finishes.

North Fork and Fire Island Pines Offerings

North Fork has emerged as a compelling alternative to The Hamptons, offering vineyard-adjacent properties and waterfront homes at a more accessible median price point of approximately $999,000. Fire Island Pines remains a sought-after enclave with distinctive architectural styles and car-free living, commanding premium prices averaging $1.88 million for its unique coastal properties.

Babylon and New Port Beach Communities

Babylon presents more affordable entry points into the Long Island market with median home prices around $650,000, attracting young professionals and families seeking community amenities and reasonable commuting distance. New Port Beach communities offer coastal living options at a median price of approximately $696,500, representing one of the better values for waterfront or water-adjacent properties in the region.

These premium neighborhoods each maintain distinct character and amenities, catering to different lifestyle preferences while consistently demonstrating strong value retention. Whether you’re looking for luxury, coastal living, or community-oriented neighborhoods, Long Island has a diverse range of options for homebuyers in 2025.

Houses for Sale in Long Island NY – Top Listings for 2025 by Price Range

Long Island’s real estate market in 2025 offers a diverse range of homes for sale across various price ranges, catering to the needs of different buyers. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer or looking to upgrade to a luxury property, Long Island has something to offer.

Entry-Level Homes ($500K-$750K)

Entry-level homes in Long Island, priced between $500K and $750K, represent approximately 30% of the current inventory. These homes typically feature 2-3 bedrooms and are located in communities like Babylon and parts of Smithtown. With modest lot sizes ranging from 0.1 to 0.25 acres, they provide essential amenities and access to quality school districts, making them ideal for first-time buyers and young families.

Mid-Range Properties ($750K-$1.5M)

The mid-range market, constituting the largest segment of Long Island’s housing inventory, offers properties priced between $750K and $1.5M. These homes usually have 3-4 bedrooms, updated interiors, and lot sizes averaging 0.25-0.5 acres. Communities such as Commack, White Plains, and parts of New Rochelle dominate this price bracket, providing a balance of space, amenities, and reasonable commuting distance to Manhattan.

Luxury Real Estate ($1.5M and Above)

Luxury properties, representing about 25% of the market, are priced at $1.5M and above. Concentrated in premium locations like The Hamptons, North Fork, and Fire Island Pines, these high-end homes often feature waterfront access, expansive grounds, and luxury amenities such as pools and guest houses. Potential buyers can explore open house information and work with reputable agencies like Compass Greater LLC or Coldwell Banker American Homes to find their dream home.

Popular Cities and Their Housing Inventory

Learn More

The real estate market in Long Island is characterized by a variety of housing choices across different cities. Homebuyers can find diverse options to suit their needs and preferences.

New Rochelle and Scarsdale Listings

New Rochelle offers diverse housing options with a median price of $879,000, featuring many 3-4 bedroom Colonial and Tudor-style homes with formal dining rooms and updated kitchens on modest-sized lots. In contrast, Scarsdale represents one of Long Island’s premium markets with a median home price of $2,524,500, characterized by larger 4-5 bedroom homes on generous lots, often featuring high-end finishes and luxury amenities.

White Plains and Smithtown Properties

White Plains provides a more accessible entry point at a median price of $799,000, with properties typically offering 3-4 bedrooms and convenient access to commuter rail lines for Manhattan professionals. Smithtown homes, priced at a median of $799,999, attract buyers seeking established neighborhoods with mature landscaping, traditional architectural styles, and strong school districts.

Commack and Manhattan Adjacent Options

Commack’s housing market centers around a median price of $829,999, featuring predominantly single-family homes with 3-4 bedrooms on quarter to half-acre lots in family-friendly neighborhoods. Manhattan-adjacent communities command premium prices (median $1,550,000) but offer the convenience of shorter commutes, attracting professionals who prioritize reduced travel time to the city.

Property Types and Special Features in Long Island

Learn More

Long Island’s real estate market offers a diverse range of property types and special features that cater to various buyer preferences. The area is known for its varied housing options, including single-family homes, condominiums, townhouses, and multi-family units.

Single-Family Homes and Condominiums

Single-family homes dominate Long Island’s real estate landscape, representing approximately 65% of available inventory. These homes vary in architectural style from traditional Colonials to modern constructions. The condominium market has also expanded significantly, with 1,191 units currently available, offering maintenance-free living options primarily concentrated in developing areas and near transportation hubs.

Townhouses and Multi-Family Units

Townhouse inventory remains limited with just 34 properties available, creating competitive bidding situations for these often more affordable alternatives to single-family homes. Multi-family units, with 160 currently listed, present investment opportunities with strong rental demand, particularly in communities like New Rochelle and parts of Smithtown.

Homes with Special Features: Pools, Vintage Charm, and Waterfront

Properties with special features are highly sought after in Long Island. Homes with pools command a premium of approximately 15-20% over comparable homes without this amenity, with the greatest concentration found in luxury markets like The Hamptons. Vintage homes with period charm and architectural significance represent approximately 12% of the market, attracting buyers seeking character features like formal dining rooms and original woodwork. Waterfront properties remain the most coveted segment, with premiums of 30-50% over comparable inland homes, offering direct water access and panoramic views.

Conclusion: Navigating Your Long Island Home Purchase in 2025

With multiple opportunities and challenges arising in 2025, buying a home in Long Island demands strategic planning. The Long Island real estate market presents a competitive landscape where properties typically stay on the market for 34 days and receive multiple offers.

To navigate this market successfully, buyers must work with experienced local agents familiar with specific neighborhoods like The Hamptons and Fire Island Pines. Financial preparation is also crucial, including securing pre-approval and understanding additional costs beyond the purchase price.

By balancing financial considerations with lifestyle priorities and remaining flexible, buyers can find their ideal home in Long Island’s diverse housing market, which offers options across all price points.